Alaska Air’s Acquisition of Hawaiian Airlines: Was the $1.9 Billion Worth It?
An independent look at the valuation, financing, regulation and synergies behind Alaska Air Group's all-cash acquisition of Hawaiian Holdings.

Photo: 4300streetcar · CC BY 4.0
On this page
I came across the Alaska Air Group–Hawaiian Holdings acquisition incidentally, but once I learnt more about the transaction, I found myself wanting to understand what made it commercially compelling and whether the benefits justified the price Alaska was willing to pay. What began as curiosity turned into an independent analysis of the acquisition, examining its valuation, financing structure, strategic rationale and potential for value creation.
Structurally, the transaction was a horizontal merger through absorption: both companies operated in the airline industry, with largely complementary networks but some overlapping routes and customer segments, while Alaska Air Group remained the surviving parent and Hawaiian became its wholly owned subsidiary. From a portfolio restructuring perspective, the acquisition brought a new set of assets, operations and capabilities under Alaska's ownership. Hawaiian's established presence in the Hawaiian Islands, its widebody fleet and transpacific network gave Alaska an opportunity to expand its geographic reach, strengthen Honolulu as a hub, extend its international operations and consolidate its position across the Pacific. The integration of the two airlines' loyalty programmes and management processes offered further opportunities to build value from the combination.
Legalities and Fancy Regulations#
While I was looking up this acquisition, I was interested to understand the legal and regulatory framework that was applicable here. First is Clayton Act Section 7, the antitrust law. It says that a company can't acquire a company whose effect may substantially lessen competition or create a monopoly. What they checked here is:
- Whether the combining airlines would reduce competition on routes where they overlapped, where the customers would lose meaningful alternatives or face higher fares.
- Whether the combined group would have greater control over important Hawaiian routes or airport access.
- Whether the merger would strengthen competition against larger airlines by creating a more capable competitor. This is what the Alaska Air submitted.
The second interesting legal framework that was applicable here is the Department of Transportation. There are clauses around:
- Will there be essential air service for communities that depend on these airlines?
- Are you protecting the inter-island service and key routes between Hawaii and the U.S.?
- Are you preserving the value of customer loyalty rewards?
- Are you ensuring smaller airlines can retain competitive access to Honolulu Airport?
- Are you prioritizing passengers from fees and service failures?
See what the Department of Transportation is looking at: aviation-specific regulations.
The third interesting regulation that this acquisition was subject to or relevant for was the Federal Aviation Administration, or FAA. This is to US what DGCA is to India. They still have some interesting requirements! Including how foreign ownership and control restrictions work. U.S. airlines are subject to citizenship requirements under federal aviation law. In general, a U.S. air carrier has restrictions on how much foreign ownership and control they can have. This was not applicable here since both were majorly US citizen owned companies, but it was an interesting clause that I came across. India also has a similar clause, individual foreign airlines can hold up to a 49% stake in an Indian scheduled passenger carrier.
Valuation Methods Used and Findings#
As part of this exercise, Barclays’ valuation analysis was available as a reference point, but I also conducted an independent analysis of the acquisition using market trading multiples and a standalone valuation of Hawaiian. I began by examining the valuation multiples of the selected airline peers, focusing on EV/Revenue, EV/EBITDA and EBITDA margins. The peers I have selected for this are Delta, United, American, Southwest and Jet Blue, in addition to Alaska.
The first observation was that every company in the peer group trades at an EV/Revenue multiple below 1.0x. This indicates that the market assigns an enterprise value of less than one dollar for every dollar of annual revenue. Such multiples can reflect several characteristics of the airline industry, including low profitability, high capital intensity, substantial debt and lease obligations, modest growth expectations and concerns about future cash flows. Within the peer group, JetBlue has the lowest EV/Revenue multiple, while Delta has the highest, at approximately 0.85x. The market therefore assigns a relatively higher enterprise value to each dollar of Delta's revenue than it does to JetBlue's.
EV/EBITDA provides a different perspective, since it measures the enterprise value assigned to each dollar of EBITDA. A higher multiple can reflect stronger growth expectations, better earnings quality, a stronger competitive position or more stable cash flows, although it can also indicate that a company is relatively expensive. JetBlue trades at 10.92x EV/EBITDA, the highest multiple among the companies with positive EBITDA. This is particularly interesting given that it has the lowest EV/Revenue multiple in the peer group. The explanation lies in its relatively low EBITDA margin: JetBlue generates less EBITDA from each dollar of revenue, so its EV/EBITDA multiple is higher despite its lower EV/Revenue multiple.
Hawaiian, meanwhile, has a negative EV/EBITDA multiple of -35.27x because its EBITDA is negative under the financial data used in the calculation. A conventional EV/EBITDA comparison is therefore not meaningful for Hawaiian; the negative multiple cannot be interpreted in the same way as the positive multiples of its peers.
Ideally, EV/EBITDAR would be the more appropriate multiple for comparing airlines because it adds rental expense back to EBITDA. This matters in an industry where airlines differ in the extent to which they own or lease their aircraft. Depreciation on owned aircraft is excluded when calculating EBITDA, whereas aircraft rental expense on leased aircraft remains an operating expense and reduces EBITDA. Consequently, an airline with a greater proportion of leased aircraft may report lower EBITDA than an otherwise comparable airline that owns more of its fleet. EBITDAR helps address this difference by adding rental expense back.
However, I could not obtain a sufficiently consistent EV/EBITDAR comparison from Bloomberg. Since the assumptions and treatment of rental expenses underlying the available EV/EBITDA figures could not be independently reconciled, I retained EV/EBITDA rather than introducing an additional rental adjustment that could compromise methodological consistency.
Using EV/Revenue as the primary comparable-company benchmark, I then estimated Hawaiian's implied enterprise value by applying the peer-group multiples to its 2023 revenue. Hawaiian itself trades at approximately 0.69x EV/Revenue. Applying the peer group's EV/Revenue range produces an implied enterprise value of approximately US$1,659 million to US$2,317 million. This provides a useful benchmark for considering how Hawaiian might have been valued had the market assigned it the same revenue multiples as the selected airline peers.
Money, Money, Money#
Alaska Air Group announced its acquisition of Hawaiian Holdings on 3 December 2023, following the execution of a definitive merger agreement on 2 December 2023. The transaction was completed on 18 September 2024. Alaska offered $18 in cash for each Hawaiian share, representing approximately 52 million shares and a common-stock consideration of approximately $936 million. A further $41 million was attributable to equity-award settlements and change-in-control obligations, taking total reported purchase consideration to approximately $977 million. The transaction was therefore structured as an all-cash acquisition: 100% of the purchase consideration was funded using Alaska's cash on hand, with no acquisition-specific debt financing or new Alaska shares issued to Hawaiian shareholders. The announced transaction value was approximately $1.9 billion, including Hawaiian's existing debt. An indicative enterprise-value bridge using acquisition-date figures gives approximately $1.879 billion: $936 million of common-stock consideration, plus approximately $1.93 billion of debt and finance leases, less $286 million of cash, $27 million of restricted cash and $674 million of marketable securities. The resulting net debt and financing obligations were approximately $943 million. It is important to distinguish this enterprise value from the $977 million purchase consideration: the former reflects the value of the operating business after accounting for debt and cash, whereas the latter represents the consideration paid to shareholders and other equity holders.
The $18 offer represented a premium of approximately 270.4% over Hawaiian's $4.86 share price. Separately, my estimate of Hawaiian's standalone equity value, based on the management projections and valuation assumptions used in my Excel model. And standalone DCF developed in this analysis produced a provisional value of approximately $9.11 per share, implying an offer premium of approximately 97.6% per share, or approximately $464 million against the modelled standalone equity value. The DCF-based premium remains provisional because the standalone valuation assumptions require further validation. The transaction also involved estimated one-time integration costs of $400–500 million, with a $450 million midpoint used in the base-case synergy model.
This financing decision is particularly interesting when viewed against the two companies' respective balance sheets. Hawaiian carried expensive debt, including borrowings backed by its loyalty programme and intellectual property. In February 2021, it had issued $1.2 billion of Senior Secured Notes at 5.75%, originally maturing in 2026. In 2024, much of these notes was exchanged into new Senior Secured Notes maturing in 2029 and carrying an 11% coupon. The collateral included Hawaiian's brand intellectual property, trademarks, domain names, HawaiianMiles loyalty-programme assets and related contractual rights. The 11% notes were issued through Hawaiian Brand Intellectual Property Ltd. and HawaiianMiles Loyalty Ltd., subsidiaries established to hold the relevant collateral, and were guaranteed by Hawaiian and related entities.
The 11% coupon is a significant indicator of the financial pressure Hawaiian was facing. Although the notes were senior secured and backed by valuable intangible assets and contractual cash flows, the borrowing cost remained exceptionally high relative to Alaska's financing costs. In November 2023, S&P had affirmed Hawaiian Holdings' credit rating at B-, with a negative outlook, citing weak credit metrics and refinancing risks associated with the loyalty notes. Hawaiian was also rated B2 by Moody's in 2023, both ratings reflecting a speculative-grade credit profile.
Alaska entered the transaction from a comparatively stronger liquidity and financing position. At 31 December 2023, its reported debt comprised approximately $80 million of fixed-rate notes, a $600 million US government Payroll Support Program note, $835 million of Enhanced Equipment Trust Certificates (EETCs) and $971 million of variable-rate notes, against total reported debt of approximately $2.471 billion. Its weighted-average interest rate was 3.4% on fixed-rate debt and 6.8% on variable-rate debt. After accounting for interest-rate swaps, the effective weighted-average rate across its debt portfolio was approximately 4.4%. Alaska also held approximately $1.79 billion in cash and marketable securities at year-end 2023.
The credit-rating comparison further illustrates the difference in the companies' financing positions immediately before the acquisition announcement. Moody's rated Alaska Baa3, its lowest investment-grade rating, while S&P rated it BB, which is speculative grade. Hawaiian was rated B- by S&P and B2 by Moody's, both speculative-grade ratings. The ratings differ by agency methodology and should therefore be considered separately rather than treated as directly interchangeable.
The merger agreement contained no financing condition, and Alaska's use of cash meant that closing was not dependent on securing a new acquisition loan. Given the liquidity available to Alaska, this was a commercially plausible financing choice. It also avoided adding a separate acquisition borrowing immediately, while leaving Hawaiian's existing debt to be addressed through a subsequent refinancing. These are financial interpretations of the disclosed decisions; the public documents do not establish that they were management's expressly stated reasons for choosing cash.
The more significant financing development came after the acquisition closed. On 15 October 2024, less than a month after closing, Alaska completed a $2 billion financing backed by its Mileage Plan loyalty-programme assets. The financing comprised $625 million of Senior Secured Notes due 2029 at a fixed interest rate of 5.021%, another $625 million of Senior Secured Notes due 2031 at 5.308%, and a $750 million Senior Secured Term Loan B due 2031 at Term SOFR plus 2.00%. The Term Loan B also provided an alternative base-rate option at a 1.00% margin.
The borrower was AS Mileage Plan IP Ltd., an indirect wholly owned subsidiary of Alaska Air Group. Bank of America acted as administrative agent and sole structuring agent, with Bank of America and Citibank serving as joint lead arrangers and bookrunners. Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley were joint lead bookrunners and arrangers, while Barclays, BNP Paribas and U.S. Bank were also bookrunners. Loop Capital Markets and PJT Advisors acted as co-managers. The $1.25 billion notes were privately offered to qualified institutional buyers under Rule 144A and to investors outside the United States under Regulation S. The named banks arranged and distributed the financing; they should not all be assumed to have been the ultimate lenders or purchasers of the notes. The Term Loan B was provided by a syndicate of lenders.
The collateral structure is also noteworthy. The financing was secured against specified Mileage Plan assets, including loyalty-programme intellectual property, customer and member data, contractual rights under partner agreements and cash flows generated by the programme. Alaska and AS Mileage Plan Holdings provided senior secured guarantees, while Alaska Air Group also provided an unsecured guarantee. Lenders received first-priority security interests over the specified collateral. This allowed Alaska to raise financing against the economic value and cash flows of its loyalty business, rather than relying solely on conventional airline assets such as aircraft.
Alaska used approximately $1.4 billion of the proceeds to repay higher-yielding debt inherited from Hawaiian, including the 11% Senior Secured Notes due 2029, the 5.75% notes due 2026 and other acquired or assumed debt. The remaining proceeds were available for other corporate purposes and liquidity support. Alaska subsequently reported annualised interest savings of approximately $30 million as a result of refinancing the higher-cost debt.
The distinction between the acquisition financing and this subsequent refinancing is important. Alaska used cash to pay Hawaiian's shareholders and settle the relevant equity awards; it raised debt after closing to refinance liabilities inherited with the acquired business. The reported $30 million represents a reduction in annual financing costs, improving profit before tax and cash flow available for investment and debt repayment. It is not additional revenue.
From an acquisition-analysis perspective, this can be classified as a financing synergy or cost-of-capital benefit. Alaska was able to use its own loyalty-programme assets and financing capacity to refinance expensive liabilities inherited from Hawaiian at a lower cost. This benefit should be considered separately from the transaction's operating synergy targets, since it arises from balance-sheet and financing optimisation rather than improvements to network, loyalty operations, cargo or operating costs.
Synergy Analysis and Value Creation#
The strategic rationale for the acquisition was to combine Alaska's strong West Coast network with Hawaiian's established presence in the Hawaiian Islands and its transpacific operations. Their complementary network positions offered Alaska an opportunity to expand its international reach and develop Honolulu as an important hub alongside Seattle. The combined network was presented as covering approximately 141 destinations, including 29 international destinations.
Hawaiian also brought capabilities that Alaska could use to expand its long-haul operations, including approximately 26 widebody aircraft comprising Airbus A330s and Boeing 787-9s, alongside its existing narrowbody fleet. The acquisition provided access to airport infrastructure, international routes, partner and codeshare connectivity, and an established workforce of pilots, cabin crew, technicians and operations personnel. These capabilities supported Alaska's expansion of long-haul services from Seattle, including routes to Tokyo and Seoul, with further expansion to destinations such as London and Rome subsequently announced. The combined network also offered opportunities to improve aircraft utilisation and passenger feed across the two airlines.
At the commercial level, the acquisition created opportunities to integrate HawaiianMiles with Alaska's Mileage Plan and to combine technology and reservation systems, airport operations, administrative functions and procurement. At the time of the announcement, management estimated $235 million in annual run-rate synergies, comprising:
Network and loyalty synergies together accounted for approximately 83% of the announced total. This indicates that the principal value-creation opportunity was expected to come from revenue and commercial benefits rather than cost reduction alone. Network integration was expected to generate value through expanded connectivity, improved route economics and better network utilisation. Loyalty integration offered opportunities to strengthen customer retention, improve partner economics and expand co-branded card opportunities. Cargo synergies were expected from the broader network and combined cargo capabilities. The $20 million net cost-saving component represented operating efficiencies after accounting for incremental costs, including wages and employee benefits.
Other potential efficiencies included technology and reservation-system integration, airport operations, administrative consolidation and improved supplier negotiations. However, these were not separately quantified in the original $235 million estimate and have therefore not been added again to the announced synergy total.
The acquisition also created a separate financial benefit through post-closing debt refinancing.
Do the Synergies Justify the Acquisition Premium?#
To assess whether the expected synergies could justify the acquisition premium, I built a model estimating the present value of after-tax synergy cash flows, less the present value of integration costs. The valuation follows two relationships:
The model uses a four-year synergy ramp, a 17% discount rate, a 25% tax assumption, a 2% terminal growth rate and a base-case integration cost of $450 million. The integration-cost estimate was based on the anticipated range of $400–500 million. These are modelling assumptions used to evaluate the transaction, rather than guaranteed management outcomes.
My standalone DCF comparison estimated the acquisition premium at approximately $464 million relative to Hawaiian's modelled standalone equity value. After discounting the expected synergies and integration costs, the model produced the following results:
| Scenario | Net present value of synergies after integration costs | Premium over standalone DCF value | Residual value created / (uncovered premium) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Low | $301.3 million | $464.0 million | ($162.6 million) |
| Base | $513.2 million | $464.0 million | $49.3 million |
| Upside | $725.1 million | $464.0 million | $261.1 million |
Under the base case, the estimated net present value of synergies after integration costs exceeds the modelled standalone equity premium by approximately $49 million. The low case leaves approximately $162.6 million of the premium uncovered, while the upside case indicates a surplus of approximately $261.1 million. The results suggest that the financial justification for the transaction depended materially on successful synergy execution.
These estimates are indicative rather than a definitive measure of realised value. They depend on the provisional standalone DCF valuation, assume that announced run-rate synergies translate into cash-flow benefits, and do not fully incorporate execution probabilities, additional reinvestment requirements or potential dis-synergies. The base-case surplus should therefore be viewed as a relatively narrow modelled margin above the acquisition premium, rather than evidence of value already realised.
What If?#
What if the acquisition had been funded, wholly or partly, through equity?
Although the actual transaction was entirely cash-funded, I examined a hypothetical stock alternative using the 1 December 2023 closing share prices of $39.73 for Alaska and $4.86 for Hawaiian. Based on these prices, the pre-announcement market exchange ratio would have been approximately 0.122 Alaska shares per Hawaiian share. Had Alaska instead settled the $18 offer entirely in its own stock, the implied exchange ratio would have been approximately 0.453 Alaska shares per Hawaiian share, resulting in the issuance of approximately 23.49 million new Alaska shares against Hawaiian's 51.82 million outstanding shares. Using Alaska's year-end 2023 share count of 126.09 million, this would have increased its share base to approximately 149.58 million, with Hawaiian shareholders owning around 15.7% of the enlarged company and existing Alaska shareholders retaining approximately 84.3%. The hypothetical issuance would therefore have increased Alaska's share count by approximately 18.6%, introducing direct ownership dilution that the actual all-cash structure avoided. A simplified EPS illustration using the companies' 2023 net income figures produces a combined net loss of approximately $25.5 million. Using Alaska's 2023 diluted weighted-average share count of 128.71 million, the indicative EPS under the actual cash structure would be approximately negative $0.20; using an adjusted diluted share count of approximately 152.20 million after the hypothetical issuance, it would be approximately negative $0.17 under an all-stock structure. These figures are illustrative and assume no other changes to earnings or capital structure; they exclude synergies, refinancing savings, acquisition accounting, integration costs and other transaction effects. The comparison highlights the trade-off: an equity-funded acquisition would have preserved more cash and avoided additional acquisition borrowing, but would have transferred a portion of the combined company's ownership to Hawaiian shareholders and increased Alaska's share count. The actual cash consideration avoided this direct share dilution, while placing the funding burden on Alaska's existing liquidity.
Conclusion#
The valuation analysis suggests that Alaska's $18-per-share offer represented a substantial premium over both Hawaiian's pre-announcement market price of $4.86 and my independently modelled standalone DCF value of approximately $9.11 per share. The valuation football field brings these benchmarks together: the DCF sensitivity range of $3.66–$15.20 per share, its base-case estimate of $9.11, and the actual $18 cash offer are shown in the equity valuation panel, while the enterprise-value panel compares the peer-derived EV/Revenue range of approximately $1.66–$2.32 billion, its median of $1.76 billion, and the indicative transaction enterprise value of approximately $1.88 billion. The two panels are kept separate because enterprise value and equity value per share are different measures. Taken together, the analysis indicates that the offer was above the standalone valuation benchmarks, placing considerable importance on the strategic and commercial benefits expected from combining the two airlines. My synergy model suggests that the present value of expected synergies, after integration costs, could cover the modelled $464 million standalone equity premium in the base and upside cases, although the low case falls short. Ultimately, the transaction's value creation depends on Alaska's ability to realise the anticipated network, loyalty and operating benefits, while managing integration costs and the financial obligations inherited from Hawaiian; the valuation results remain indicative and depend on the assumptions used in the standalone DCF and synergy models.

